JoeThePirate wins by achievements!

JoeThePirate:
    initial hand: Metalworking1 and Clothing1
    achievement(s):  1 – Prehistory Monument 2 – Classical 3 – Medieval 4 – Renaissance 5 – Exploration
    score: (29) 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 3 3
     Printing Press4 Writing1
    Enterprise4
    Invention4 Sailing1 Clothing1
    Industrialization6 Engineering3 Metalworking1
    0  0  5  5  3  0 

Kurgan:
    initial hand: Domestication1 and Masonry1
    achievement(s):  Empire
    score: (5) 1 4
    Physics5 Mathematics2 Chemistry5
     Mysticism1 Societies5 Emancipation6
    Compass3 Currency2
    Canning6 Masonry1 Steam Engine5 Vaccination6
     Coal5 Construction2 Oars1
    5  2  3  4  7  0 

Game log

JoeThePirate melds Clothing1 and goes first.
Kurgan melds Masonry1.


— JoeThePirate's turn 1 —
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Clothing1.
... JoeThePirate melds Metalworking1.
... JoeThePirate draws and scores Agriculture1 and Code of Laws1.


— Kurgan's turn 1 —
Kurgan draws Oars1.
Kurgan draws Mysticism1.


— JoeThePirate's turn 2 —
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Metalworking1.
...  effects are shared with Kurgan.
... Kurgan draws Pottery1.
... JoeThePirate draws and scores City States1.
... JoeThePirate draws and scores Tools1.
... JoeThePirate draws Writing1.
... JoeThePirate draws Sailing1 as a sharing bonus.
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Clothing1.
... JoeThePirate melds Writing1.
... JoeThePirate draws and scores The Wheel1, Road Building2, and Fermenting2.


— Kurgan's turn 2 —
Kurgan draws Canal Building2.
Kurgan draws Currency2.


— JoeThePirate's turn 3 —
JoeThePirate achieves age 1 – Prehistory!
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Clothing1.
... JoeThePirate has no card to meld.
... JoeThePirate draws and scores Calendar2, Monotheism2, and Philosophy2.


— Kurgan's turn 3 —
Kurgan draws Mathematics2.
Kurgan draws Construction2.


— JoeThePirate's turn 4 —
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Clothing1.
... JoeThePirate has no card to meld.
... JoeThePirate draws and scores Medicine3, Machinery3, and Feudalism3.
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Clothing1.
... JoeThePirate has no card to meld.
... JoeThePirate draws and scores Alchemy3, Paper3, and Translation3.
... JoeThePirate achieves Monument!


— Kurgan's turn 4 —
Kurgan applies the dogma of Masonry1.
...  effects are shared with JoeThePirate.
... JoeThePirate melds nothing.
... Kurgan melds Domestication1, Oars1, Mysticism1, and Construction2.
Kurgan melds Currency2.


— JoeThePirate's turn 5 —
JoeThePirate melds Sailing1.
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Sailing1.
...  effects are shared with Kurgan.
... Kurgan draws and melds Compass3.
... JoeThePirate draws and melds Engineering3.
... JoeThePirate draws Optics3 as a sharing bonus.


— Kurgan's turn 5 —
Kurgan melds Mathematics2.
Kurgan applies the dogma of Construction2.
...  demands are made of JoeThePirate.
... JoeThePirate transfers Optics3 to Kurgan's hand.
... JoeThePirate draws Invention4.
... Kurgan achieves Empire!


— JoeThePirate's turn 6 —
JoeThePirate achieves age 2 – Classical!
JoeThePirate achieves age 3 – Medieval!


— Kurgan's turn 6 —
Kurgan applies the dogma of Mysticism1.
... Kurgan draws and melds Anatomy4 and then draws Navigation4.
Kurgan applies the dogma of Anatomy4.
...  demands are made of JoeThePirate.
... JoeThePirate returns Monotheism2 from their score pile.
... JoeThePirate has no top 2 to return.


— JoeThePirate's turn 7 —
JoeThePirate melds Invention4.
JoeThePirate achieves age 4 – Renaissance!


— Kurgan's turn 7 —
Kurgan applies the dogma of Mathematics2.
...  effects are shared with JoeThePirate.
... JoeThePirate has no card to return.
... Kurgan returns Navigation4.
... Kurgan draws and melds Coal5.
Kurgan applies the dogma of Coal5.
... Kurgan draws and tucks Steam Engine5.
... Kurgan splays his red cards right.
... Kurgan scores nothing.


— JoeThePirate's turn 8 —
JoeThePirate draws Printing Press4.
JoeThePirate draws Reformation4.


— Kurgan's turn 8 —
Kurgan applies the dogma of Coal5.
... Kurgan draws and tucks Chemistry5.
... Kurgan scores Anatomy4 and Domestication1.
Kurgan applies the dogma of Coal5.
... Kurgan draws and tucks Societies5.
... Kurgan scores nothing.


— JoeThePirate's turn 9 —
JoeThePirate melds Printing Press4.
JoeThePirate draws Enterprise4.


— Kurgan's turn 9 —
Kurgan draws Physics5.
Kurgan melds Physics5.


— JoeThePirate's turn 10 —
JoeThePirate melds Enterprise4.
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Printing Press4.
... JoeThePirate returns City States1 from their score pile.
... JoeThePirate draws Metric System6.
... JoeThePirate splays their blue cards right.


— Kurgan's turn 10 —
Kurgan applies the dogma of Physics5.
...  effects are shared with JoeThePirate.
... JoeThePirate draws Democracy6, Emancipation6, and Machine Tools6.
... JoeThePirate returns Reformation4, Emancipation6, Machine Tools6, Metric System6, and Democracy6.
... Kurgan draws Encyclopedia6, Classification6, and Industrialization6.
... Kurgan draws Measurement5 as a sharing bonus.
Kurgan melds Industrialization6.


— JoeThePirate's turn 11 —
JoeThePirate applies the dogma of Printing Press4.
... JoeThePirate returns Code of Laws1 from their score pile.
... JoeThePirate draws Canning6.
JoeThePirate melds Canning6.


— Kurgan's turn 11 —
Kurgan applies the dogma of Industrialization6.
... Kurgan draws and tucks Vaccination6 and Emancipation6.
... Kurgan splays his purple cards right.
Kurgan applies the dogma of Compass3.
...  demands are made of JoeThePirate.
... JoeThePirate transfers Canning6 to Kurgan's board.
... JoeThePirate transfers Industrialization6 from Kurgan's board to theirs.


— JoeThePirate's turn 12 —
JoeThePirate achieves age 5 – Exploration!


JoeThePirate wins by achievements!